One in three supporters ‘barely noticing’ or ‘actively avoiding’ charity communications

Charity supporters are actively switching off from communications being sent to them by good causes, research has found.

One in three supporters say they are “disengaging from charity communications, either by barely noticing them or actively avoiding them”.

Charities overlooking donor preferences is a factor, suggests the research by digital agency Manifesto, which surveyed 1,600 supporters and 300 charity workers.

Researchers found that while four in five supporters say having control over how they are contacted is important, only around one in five of charities record individual preferences.

Another factor, suggests researchers, is the use of pressure tactics. One in three supporters cite “guilt-heavy or pushy communications” as a reason for swerving charity communications. Three in ten warn they are being asked for money too often.

Donor preferences are also impacted by “internal silos” with individual teams more focus on their own targets.

“Engagement is fragile, hard to build and easy to break,” said Manifesto chief executive Louise Lai.

“But closing the gap between what supporters need and the experiences we deliver is a significant opportunity for the sector to build stronger relationships and overcome today's challenges.”

Manifesto also found that more than half of supporters believe charities do essential work that wouldn’t happen otherwise, and only one in 100 former supporters have stopped giving to good causes entirely.

Improving donor experiences

Charities are being urged to carry out an audit of communications to identify where these are being poorly timed or issued too frequently.

They are also urged to use frequency caps on communications and to set flexible contact limits and ensure they are asking for and recording supporter’ communication preferences.

Ensuring supporters are thanked effectively is also important as only just under half say they felt appreciated after their last gift.

“Showing supporters the difference their donation makes before asking again is one of the quickest ways to build loyalty,” said Manifesto.

Among charity leaders spoken to by researchers is Compass founder Lesley Pinder, who said: "Pick a journey, pick a supporter type, find out all about them and try to make their experience better."

Joanne Dunsford, global director of fundraising and communications at Animals Asia, said: “To successfully move to an audience led model, you need to make an operational shift and a mindset shift. Until everyone is thinking about the whole experience, we’re not there.”



Share Story:

Recent Stories


Video Q&A: In conversation with Vicki Sellick MBE, CEO of Good Things Foundation
Vicki Sellick MBE, CEO of Good Things Foundation joins Charity Times editor, Lauren Weymouth to discuss her leadership journey, the organisation’s new strategy and the findings of the Digital Nation 2026 report. She explores the challenges of digital inclusion, the opportunities and risks of AI, and how the sector can ensure nobody is left behind.

Video Q&A: Benefits of bespoke investment vs pooled funds for the third sector
In this Charity Times video Q&A, editor Lauren Weymouth speaks to Ed Caswell of RBC Brewin Dolphin to explore how charities can align investment strategies with their mission, balance income and growth, and adapt to changing needs. He discusses discretionary management, responsible investment and the importance of effective governance and regular portfolio reviews.

Charity Times Awards 2023