Financial governance arrangements at a defunct charity, which ran a contemporary arts venue in Glasgow, have been criticised in a report by the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator (OSCR).
The report follows the regulator’s probe into the charity’s closure earlier this year of Centre for Contemporary Arts, focusing on the level of oversight and governance by trustees rather than the decision to enter insolvency itself.
This found that financial information made available to trustees “was not always sufficiently robust, and, as a result, opportunities for the Board to identify and address some financial risks at an earlier stage were not always available”.
Also, “formal governance arrangements were not as robust as they could have been during the period under review”, found the OSCR, which added, “although Trustee meetings were held frequently, formal records of board decisions were not consistently minuted, albeit extensive email records have been maintained”.
Despite the concerns the regulator found that as “concerns about the charity’s financial position emerged, the trustees increased their oversight, sought professional advice, engaged with funders and explored a range of measures aimed at stabilising the charity’s position”.
Its report added: “The evidence reviewed by OSCR showed that trustees were actively involved in discussions regarding financial risks, funding challenges and the future sustainability of the organisation.”
The regulator also recognises the “immediate action” taken by trustees once financial problems were known.
However, the OSCR has concluded there is “a reasonable basis for some concern regarding weaknesses in the charity's financial reporting arrangements, formal record keeping and the overall resilience of the board's governance arrangements”.
As the charity has closed down, the regulator says that any recommendations around improving financial oversight are best addressed to trustees should they take up any future charity roles, said the regulator, which has closed its inquiry and said that no further regulatory action is required.
Venue's future
During the summer union the Scottish Trades Union Congress (STUC) urged funder Creative Scotland to stop its sale of the former site of Centre for Contemporary Arts following its insolvency.
The union wants to ensure the building in Sauchiehall Street, Glasgow, which is owned by the funder, remains in public hands. They also want to see a public consultation opened on its future.
Earlier this month Creative Scotland announced that it has received nine bids expressing interest in either buying or leasing the former charity’s site. All are looking to run it as a cultural venue.





Recent Stories