31/07/12

By Andrew Holt

Public concern about advertising by charities is prominent in new research released today by the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA).

The study entitled Public perceptions of harm and offence in UK advertising, conducted by Ipsos MORI on behalf of the ASA, reports that "hard hitting charity ads" are given as a top spontaneous example of harmful and offensive material.

Participants in the study argued that charity adverts can go too far, using distressing content to make people feel upset or guilty in a way that was considered inappropriate.

Conversely, some felt adverts should have more scope to shock because of their worthwhile aims.

There were also widespread concerns about the impact on children of adverts using strong imagery to depict suffering or mistreatment, with parents reporting that children had been upset and worried about being unable to help.

There was also a feeling that ads targeting children’s channels were perceived as being intended to engage children’s emotions so they would ask parents to donate.

Colin Lloyd, chair of the Fundraising Standards Board (FRSB) believes this latest research from the ASA should enable charities to get a clearer understanding of what is likely to cause public offense in advertising and he welcomes findings that can provide a valuable insight for the charity sector.

He said: “It is clear there is a balance to be struck between charities’ needs to build causal awareness and public support with risk to their reputations from the negative impact of advertising that is felt to be distressing.

“The study recognises that offence is highly personal and subjective, and, encouragingly, that there is understanding that charities need to make an emotional connection with the public.

"The charity sector has the support of robust codes of best practice reflecting today’s media landscape, which together with its investment in self-regulation, can help identify the all-important balance.

"Every charity must be responsible in following best practice and in every case should be asking themselves where they draw the line to ensure advertisements are compatible with their mission and values without being offensive or guilt laden.”

A full copy of the research Public perceptions of harm and offence in UK advertising can be seen on the ASA website: www.asa.org.uk.

Home     More News


Other stories you may find of interest:

Iof launches new Code of Fundraising Practice
The Institute of Fundraising (Iof) has today launched a new, single Code of Fundraising Practice underpinned by the four key principles - legal, open, honest and respectful - that places the IoF at the heart of self-regulation in the sector. Launching the Code, Stephen Pidgeon, chair of the IoF Standards Committee that initiated and led the development of the new code, said: “I'm immensely proud that after a year of consultation and hard work by many IoF staff and members we have reduced the 28 original Codes of Fundraising Practice to one. They were long and repetitive, and in some cases contradictory.

Regulator endorses YMCA Insync 2010 quality standard
The Charity Commission has endorsed the Insync 2010 Quality Standards of the National Council of YMCAs. This comes as part of the Commission’s Quality Standards Endorsement Progamme, which supports the development of quality standards used to assess how well charities are run. YMCA England (212810) is the umbrella body for the 135 independent YMCAs working across England to support young people, especially in times of need or crisis. The Insync 2010 standards define best practice for individual YMCAs and will be used to accredit those YMCAs that achieve the standards.

Alcohol marketing messages getting through to children
A new report from Alcohol Concern shows that children as young as 10 are more familiar with some leading alcohol brands and adverts than those for popular foods and snacks. The report Making an impression describes the findings from a new study of over 400 primary school pupils, which looked at the extent to which they were aware of alcohol branding and advertising.