20/04/10
By
The National Coalition for Independent Action today released an open letter to the chief executives of the five national bodies, which have endorsed the revised National Compact, launched on December 16.
The full text of the letter reads:
Dear Stephen, Debra, Stuart, Kevin and Justin,
We write this open letter to you, having been confronted by your ringing endorsement of the 'Refreshed Compact'.
Over here at the NCIA we have long taken a critical view, both of the Compact and the industry that has been created to promote its goodness and effectiveness. Nothing has changed in that department.
The Compact is still a fig leaf for unequal power relationships.
But the reason why we are now spending time on it is because the whole 'refresh' process, culminating in the December 16th launch and your own contribution to this, so vividly illustrates what we have been complaining about in the sector for the last three years.
The relentless orthodoxy that there is only good news out there; that the sector is thriving and partnerships with government and their agents at local level are harmonious, successful and effective; and, that any disagreement with this version of events is seen off as misinformed, mischief-making or ignorant.
What we see is a rather different picture, in which a large amount of public money has now been spent on the Compact good news industry, and where the new version of the document:
pretty faithfully reflects what the government wants it to say
was built on a grossly inadequate consultation exercise (79 responses from 179,000 charities - never mind the hundreds of thousands of non-charitable community groups) and involved ignoring the views and recommendations of some of those most closely involved in the process (via the Compact Refresh Panel)
has ended up with a worse document to the one that preceded it, which focuses on the procurement/contract/privatisation agenda, marginalises (again) the community sector, and totally dumps equalities issues
retains the voluntary code idea that all good people will, of course, take their Compact obligations seriously, so obviously flying in the face of the evidence
and, to add a chilling Orwellian echo, promotes the reclassification from the Single Equalities Bill of 'people with protected characteristics'.
Meanwhile state agencies (right up to the OTS Minister herself) continue to ignore or flout Compact compliance and the bulk of the sector remains quite unsurprised by all this, having long since realised that the Compact, despite its tactical use by a few plucky local activists, is hardly at the cutting edge of helpfulness in their relationship with statutory agencies.
Even the evident focus on public service privatisation and the sector's assumed role in this, is na
Other stories you may find of interest:
Third Sector ministers go head to head via DSC
Angela Smith, Nick Hurd, and Jenny Willott have shared contrasting views about the role of charities in campaigning for change, in response to questions posed by the Directory of Social Change (DSC). Among a series of five questions on key policy issues, DSC asked the Minister and Shadow Ministers for the three main political parties 'how would life be different for campaigning charities?' if their party won the election.
DSC gives its verdict on the Giving Green Paper
The Directory of Social Change (DSC) has given its assessment of the Green Giving Paper stating it is an important area of work, and supports the aim to increase levels of giving and mutual support in society and to catalyse a culture shift that makes social action a social norm. Though, the DSC says what it brings to the debate with its assessment is that in the green paper and in the wider discussion to date, there is generally too much emphasis on giving more, and relatively little about how we can give better or give well.
Sector welcomes Giving White Paper
Sector organistions have broadly welcomed the Government's Giving White Paper published today. ACEVO, NCVO, CFDG, CAF, IOF, Volunteering England and the Philanthropy Review all welcome the paper, albeit with different levels of qualification. The Social Enterprise Coalition's Peter Holbrook and the DSC are the most critical....
The European Union is one of the largest donors to civil society in the world, but also accused of not truly engaging with sector organisations. Peter Davy investigates the EU/sector relationship
Current struggles over the Eurozone debt crisis have done little to endear the EU to British voters, it seems. Two polls in July had half the population saying they would vote to leave were a referendum held. In the survey by pollsters AngusReid, only a third thought EU membership had been positive for the country...
With morale in the sector at its lowest ebb, Duncan Jefferies asks what makes an effective leader and how charities can attract and develop the best management talent in the current environment
Andrew Holt investigates the vital and often unique work taken on by faith charities, the
part they play in the Big Society, and how they will survive in a testing environment
Faith-based charities form a significant part of the charitable sector, with 30,115 charities in England and Wales focusing on religious activities,equating to a shared income of £6.643 billion....
